Determine if you need a simple step tracker, a GPS running watch, or a smartwatch. Pay close attention to whether advanced sleep and health metrics require an ongoing paid subscription.
Updated Apr 6, 2026

Garmin
Garmin Edge 540 GPS Cycling Computer
010-02694-00
$349.99
Charging costs are virtually zero. However, many fitness trackers lock their best health insights behind monthly subscription paywalls.
Common Failure Modes
Battery degradation is the most common issue, reducing multi-day batteries to daily charging. Water damage over time from compromised seals is also frequent.
Determine if you need a simple step tracker, a GPS running watch, or a smartwatch. Pay close attention to whether advanced sleep and health metrics require an ongoing paid subscription.
Trackers last 2-4 years. The bands break and batteries fail.
Top-rated fitness trackers brands include Fitbit, Garmin, WHOOP, Fantom and more. Covala Shopping tracks 15 fitness trackers from 4+ brands.
Charging costs are virtually zero. However, many fitness trackers lock their best health insights behind monthly subscription paywalls.
Links may earn Covala Shopping a commission at no extra cost to you. Prices last verified at time of page load. As an Amazon Associate, Covala Shopping earns from qualifying purchases.